Steak sandwiches and steak dinners at P&G’s in New Paltz, NY put beef at the center of your meal, with pickup available for your order.
Order onlineFlat Iron
$25.95+
Eight-ounce flat iron steak with your choice of doneness.
“This place has a nice hometown feel. The server was really attentive and helpful. She recommended a smaller steak for us which was perfect! It came with fresh bread that was super tasty and paired really well with the french onion soup”
NY Strip
$35.95+
A 12-ounce New York strip steak cooked to your chosen temperature.
“Very friendly server staff. We came specifically for the prime rib, which was perfect.”
Open Steak Sandwich
$18.95+
Charbroiled flat iron steak on toast, topped with crispy fried onions.
“The open faced steak sandwich and French dip are both great.”
P&G’s serves steak as a sandwich or a dinner, with flat iron and New York strip cuts. Seafood and cheese additions are available for the steak dinners, pairing the beef with shrimp, scallops, or a blue cheese crust.
Open Steak Sandwich has charbroiled flat iron on toast with crispy fried onions. NY Strip is a 12 oz. cut, while Flat Iron is 8 oz.; both offer a baked potato or French fries alongside your steak.
Visit P&G’s in New Paltz, NY for dine-in, or order pickup or delivery. You can have your steak cooked rare, medium, or well done, with a Caesar salad or a cup of soup to accompany a steak dinner.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
P&G’s offers kid-friendly options, including Kids Grilled Chz and Kids Burger.
Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.
