Grilled and fried sandwiches meet deli-style fillings at P&G’s in New Paltz, NY, with pickup available for your sandwich order.
Order onlineChicken BLT
$15.95+
Fried chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on a toasted club roll.
“Sevice is always great! Highly recommend their wraps with eggplant fries. Salads are hearty enough for dinner. The chicken BLT sandwich is big enough to share.”
Chx Breast Sandwich
$13.95+
Grilled chicken breast on a toasted kaiser roll with lettuce and tomato.
Crispy Chx Sandwich
$14.95+
Breaded chicken cutlet, deep-fried and served on a hard roll.
Buff Chx Crispy Sand
$14.95+
Crispy Buffalo chicken, lettuce, tomato and blue cheese on a hard roll.
1/2 Roast Beef
$11.95+
A half roast beef sandwich with your choice of bread and accompaniments.
“Lulu was great. Had the chili, half rst beef sandwich and southwestern chicken salad all were delicious”
Pastrami Sand
$9.95+
Pastrami sandwich with chosen bread and a deli side, or no side.
“A classic New Paltz restaurant serving up standard pub fare. Visited in October of 2022 and was amazed to see their prices are still very reasonable, with many sandwiches under $13. Portions are large and food is tasty. Service was friendly and quick. Great to see this place survive the pandemic and still doing well.”
Roast Beef Sand
$9.95+
Roast beef sandwich with chosen bread and a choice of deli side or none.
“Nice sandwiches and drinks. Nice friendly barmaid also Tuesday afternoon visit”
Grilled Cheese
$8.95+
Grilled cheese sandwich with your choice of bread and cheese.
“Onion soup was awesome along with half a grilled cheese. All delicious.”
Turkey Club
$14.95+
Turkey, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo on chosen bread with a side.
“Been going to P and G's over the past five decades and they only get better. Had lunch today and ordered the Pulled Pork Quesadilla with sweet potato fries. Wow, what a great idea...pulled pork and cheese in a grilled shell? Delicious! Our serving staff was attentive and very nice. Food came out quickly and looked great. My brothers ordered the Club Sandwiches which they loved. A meal for four came to $77. Not bad. This is a great place to eat and drink. Enjoy.”
Ham&Chz Club
$14.95+
Ham, cheese, bacon, lettuce, tomato, and mayo in a club sandwich.
At P&G’s, sandwiches range from grilled chicken with Cajun or BBQ flavor to salmon on toasted garlic bread with lettuce and tomato. Deli sandwiches include pastrami, roast beef and honey ham.
Turkey Reuben layers sauerkraut, Swiss and Russian dressing on grilled rye. P&G's Dip pairs roast beef and melted provolone with dipping jus. Chicken BLT has a fried cutlet and bacon on a toasted club roll.
Visit us in New Paltz, NY for pickup, dine-in or delivery. The Godmother has fried eggplant, fresh mozzarella, spinach, fire-roasted tomatoes and pesto mayo on a toasted club roll, with corn as a side option.
Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.
P&G’s offers kid-friendly options, including Kids Grilled Chz and Kids Burger.
Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.
