Fish in New Paltz

Cajun-spiced salmon and fried seafood anchor fish at P&G’s in New Paltz, NY, with sandwiches and dinners available for pickup.

Order online

Fish to Try

Salmon Dinner

Salmon with a choice of broiled, grilled, Cajun or glazed preparation.

Grilled Salmon Dinner$27.95Atlantic salmon grilled and served with a side salad, broccoli, and rice.
Cajun Salmon Dinner$27.95Atlantic salmon seasoned Cajun-style and served with a side salad, broccoli, and rice.
Broiled Salmon Dinner$27.95Atlantic salmon broiled and served with a side salad, broccoli, and rice.
Sesame Glazed Salmon Dinner$27.95Atlantic salmon with sesame glaze, served with a side salad, broccoli, and rice.

Caj Salmon Sand

$17.95+

Grilled Cajun-spiced salmon on toasted garlic bread with lettuce and tomato.

“Great place to eat n have a drink... Love the salmon...”

Fried Seafood Platter

$25.95+

Fried haddock, clams, and shrimp with slaw and two sauces.

Salmon Sandwich

$17.95+

Grilled salmon on toasted garlic bread with lettuce and tomato.

Something for Everyone at P&G’s

P&G’s serves fish as salmon sandwiches, a salmon dinner and a fried seafood platter. Sandwiches pair salmon with bread, while the platter combines fish and shellfish on the same plate.

Caj Salmon Sand has Cajun spice; Salmon Sandwich has grilled salmon on toasted garlic bread with lettuce and tomato. Fried Seafood Platter pairs haddock, clams and shrimp with cole slaw, tartar and cocktail sauce.

Visit P&G’s in New Paltz, NY for pickup, dine-in or delivery. Salmon Dinner features fresh Atlantic salmon, with broiled, grilled, Cajun-spiced or sesame-glazed preparations and a baked potato side option.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular fish options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

Caj Salmon Sand — Grilled Cajun-spiced salmon comes on garlic toast with lettuce and tomato; choose one side, including chips, baked potato, or coleslaw.
Salmon Dinner — The salmon can be broiled, grilled, Cajun-spiced or sesame-glazed; dinner also includes a required soup or salad selection and sides.
Fried Seafood Platter — The fried seafood assortment includes haddock, clams, and shrimp, with cole slaw, tartar sauce, and cocktail sauce served alongside.
Salmon Sandwich — A grilled salmon fillet is served on toasted garlic bread with lettuce and tomato; choose one required side from the listed options.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for fish throughout the New Paltz area. Order your fish online for convenient pickup or delivery.

Is there a kids menu?

P&G’s offers kid-friendly options, including Kids Grilled Chz and Kids Burger.

Explore our menu to see all the options for your next family meal.